If your checkout still looks like “Visa, Mastercard and maybe PayPal,” you’re quietly leaking revenue. In 2025, customers expect to see digital wallets, Buy Now Pay Later, and even pay‑by‑bank—yet bolting on every shiny new option just bloats fees and kills conversion.
This guide gives you a practical, no‑fluff way to decide which payment methods your website actually needs based on who you sell to, where they live, and how big your average order is.
The New Checkout Reality: Wallets First, Cards Second
In 2025, **digital wallets have overtaken cards as the default way many consumers pay online**, especially on mobile.[8] Customers expect to tap Apple Pay, Google Pay, or PayPal and be done in seconds, without hunting for a card or typing 16 digits.
Most leading payment gateways now treat wallets as core, not optional extras. Stripe, PayPal, Square, Adyen, and Amazon Pay all bundle wallets alongside cards in their standard offerings.[1][2][5]
Here’s what that looks like in practice:
- Stripe: Supports cards plus Apple Pay, Google Pay, Alipay, WeChat Pay, Cash App Pay and local wallets, with pricing typically around 2.9% + $0.30 per successful card transaction in many markets.[1]
- PayPal: Still one of the most recognized names online, with over 400M users worldwide and one‑click checkout, PayPal balance, PayPal Pay Later, and card acceptance via its branded checkout.[5][3]
- Square: Online payments around 2.9% + $0.30, with Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Cash App Pay built in—great if you sell both online and in‑person.[1][4]
Action step: If you only do one thing this quarter, make sure your checkout clearly offers both cards and at least one major wallet (PayPal or Apple/Google Pay) on desktop and mobile. That alone can reduce friction and cart abandonment.[1][2][7]
The Big Four Payment “Building Blocks”
Think of your website’s payment stack like a menu with four core categories.
1. Credit & Debit Cards – The Non‑Negotiable Baseline
Every serious online business still needs to accept major cards (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover).[1][2] Gateways like Stripe, PayPal, Square, Adyen, Worldpay, and Shopify Payments all cover this out of the box.[1][2][7]
Typical online pricing in 2025:
- Stripe: Around 2.9% + $0.30 per successful card transaction for many small businesses (varies by country).[1][2]
- PayPal: Often around 2.89–3.49% + ~$0.30–$0.49 per online transaction, with higher fees for international and currency conversion.[3][4]
- Square: About 2.9% + $0.30 online.[1][4]
- Shopify Payments: 2.9% + $0.30 on the Basic plan, with lower rates on higher tiers—and no extra transaction fee when you use their own gateway.[4][5]
Who absolutely needs cards? Almost every website, especially if you serve multiple age groups or B2B buyers. Even though wallets, BNPL and bank payments are booming, cards remain the catch‑all fallback.[8]
2. Digital Wallets – Your Conversion Booster
Digital wallets like Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal are now among the most popular online payment method types in 2025, especially on mobile.[8] They offer one‑tap checkout with tokenized card details, reducing friction and fraud.
How leading providers handle wallets:[1][2][5]
- PayPal (and Braintree): PayPal wallet + cards, plus options like Venmo in the US.[5][6]
- Stripe: Apple Pay, Google Pay, Cash App Pay, Alipay, WeChat Pay, plus support for local wallets in specific markets.[1]
- Adyen: Apple Pay, Google Pay, Cash App Pay and PayPal (via separate contract), tuned for global brands.[1][2]
When wallets are critical:
- Your traffic is heavily mobile (DTC brands, social media ads, influencers).
- You sell to younger demographics (Gen Z, younger millennials), who are used to Apple Pay and PayPal on every checkout.[8]
- You want to visibly signal security and trust to first‑time buyers—PayPal’s brand recognition is a powerful form of social proof.[3][5]
3. Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) – AOV and Conversion Weapon
BNPL has matured from a trendy add‑on to a mainstream expectation for higher‑ticket consumer purchases in 2025.[8] Services like Klarna, Afterpay/Clearpay, Affirm and Zip let customers split payments into installments while you, the merchant, still get paid upfront.
How BNPL shows up inside major gateways:[1][6]
- Stripe: Supports Klarna, Afterpay/Clearpay, Affirm and Zip in many regions, with you paid upfront and customers paying over time.[1]
- Square: Integrates Afterpay, ideal for ecommerce + in‑person retailers wanting a unified BNPL offer.[1]
- Adyen: Offers multiple BNPLs (Affirm, Afterpay, Klarna, Zip), focused on mid‑market and enterprise merchants.[1]
- Amazon Pay: Can tap Affirm installments as an add‑on.[1]
BNPL typically carries slightly higher fees than standard card processing, but it can significantly increase average order value and checkout conversion for orders above roughly $100.[1][8]
Use BNPL when:
- Your average order value (AOV) is consistently over $100–$150 (fashion, furniture, electronics, high‑end beauty).
- You sell to younger, credit‑averse shoppers who prefer splitting purchases over using credit cards.[8]
- You’re in competitive verticals where rivals already show Klarna/Afterpay logos on product pages—opt‑out here and you risk FOMO‑driven cart abandonment.
4. Pay‑by‑Bank & Local Methods – Hidden Margin and Trust Play
Open‑banking “pay by bank” and local payment methods are 2025’s quiet disruptors. Instead of card rails, they connect directly to bank accounts, often with lower fees and fewer chargebacks.[1][8]
Examples in leading platforms:[1]
- Stripe: ACH, SEPA, Bacs, PayNow, plus local transfer methods depending on region.
- Adyen: ACH Direct Debit and Pay by Bank (via Plaid) alongside cards and wallets.
Local favorites matter too—think iDEAL in the Netherlands, Klarna Pay Now in parts of Europe, and PayNow in Singapore.[1][8]
Where pay‑by‑bank shines:
- High‑ticket orders ($500+), where small fee differences really add up.
- Subscription or invoice‑driven businesses (B2B, SaaS, agencies) where bank debits reduce churn and chargebacks.
- Markets where cards are distrusted or less widely held, but bank accounts are common.
How to Choose Your Perfect Payment Mix (In 5 Decisions)
Instead of starting from a list of providers, start from your business profile. Use this simple decision framework to avoid both under‑offering and checkout bloat.
Step 1: Map Your Audience by Age & Device
Ask:
- Are most buyers under 35, or mixed/older?
- Is 60%+ of traffic from mobile?
If yes to either, treat digital wallets as mandatory, not optional. At minimum: cards + Apple/Google Pay + PayPal.[1][5][7]
Step 2: Check Your Geography
Where are 80% of your orders coming from?
- US/UK/Canada/Australia: Cards + wallets + BNPL will cover the majority of demand. Providers like Stripe, Square, Shopify Payments, PayPal or Amazon Pay are strong fits.[1][2][7]
- EU & UK with cross‑border sales: Add SEPA/SEPA Direct Debit and local options through Stripe or Adyen. Consider Klarna for both BNPL and local pay‑now preferences.[1][2][8]
- APAC: Look at local wallets and bank transfers such as PayNow, Alipay, and WeChat Pay via Stripe or Adyen.[1][8]
Rule of thumb: Add a local method when at least ~10% of your revenue comes from a specific country that strongly prefers it.[1]
Step 3: Look at Your Average Order Value (AOV)
Your AOV dictates whether BNPL and pay‑by‑bank are “nice to have” or conversion engines:
- AOV under $80: Cards + wallets usually enough. BNPL often isn’t worth the added complexity and higher fees for very low‑ticket items.
- AOV $80–$250: BNPL can meaningfully lift conversion and unlock upsells and bundles. Stripe + Klarna/Afterpay or Square + Afterpay are straightforward options.[1]
- AOV $250+: Combine BNPL on the front end with bank transfers/direct debits for larger B2B or invoice‑based orders.
Step 4: Match to Your Business Model
Different stacks suit different models:
- DTC ecommerce brand: Shopify + Shopify Payments (cards + wallets) + Shop Pay Installments or third‑party BNPL; or WooCommerce + Stripe/PayPal + BNPL.
- Service or coaching business: Stripe or PayPal for one‑off payments, plus ACH/SEPA debits for retainers. Use built‑in recurring billing tools.[1][3]
- Retail with a physical store: Square for unified POS + online, including Apple Pay, Google Pay and Afterpay.[1][4]
- High‑growth international brand: Adyen or Stripe with custom pricing, advanced risk tools, and broad local method coverage.[1][2]
Step 5: Sanity‑Check Fees vs. Trust
Price anchoring matters. A gateway that looks slightly more expensive per transaction can still win if it dramatically improves conversion and reduces disputes.
- Compare core online card fees: ~2.9% + $0.30 (Stripe, Square, Shopify Payments) vs 2.89–3.49% + $0.30–$0.49 (PayPal).[1][3][4]
- Remember what you “buy” with that fee: brand trust (PayPal), built‑in analytics (Stripe), or native platform integration (Shopify Payments).[2][4][7]
Don’t race to the bottom on fees if it means losing the logos and experience that make customers feel safe enough to hit “Pay now.”
A Simple 3‑Tier Setup You Can Implement This Week
To avoid paralysis, pick the tier that best matches your stage and implement it in the next 7 days.
Starter Stack (Launching or Validating an Idea)
- Core methods: Cards + one major wallet.
- Suggested setup:
- Shopify store: Turn on Shopify Payments (cards + wallets) and PayPal Express.
- WordPress/WooCommerce: Install Stripe + PayPal plugins.
- Why: Fastest setup, minimal tech, covers 80%+ of customer expectations.[1][2][7]
Growth Stack (Scaling AOV and Volume)
- Core methods: Cards + wallets + BNPL + at least one local method where relevant.
- Suggested setup:
- Add Klarna/Afterpay/Affirm via Stripe, Square, or a direct integration.[1]
- Enable SEPA/ACH or local transfers in your gateway for key markets (e.g., SEPA in EU, PayNow in Singapore).[1]
- Why: Captures more hesitant buyers, raises AOV, and unlocks international growth.
Pro Stack (High Volume or Multi‑Region Brand)
- Core methods: Full mix of cards, wallets, BNPL, pay‑by‑bank, and key local options.
- Suggested setup:
- Negotiate custom pricing with Stripe, Adyen, or Worldpay.[1][2]
- Enable advanced risk tools, 3D Secure, and bank debits for subscriptions.
- Run A/B tests on checkout layout and which logos appear at each step.
- Why: At scale, small conversion and fee optimizations compound into substantial profit.
Your Next Move: Audit and Upgrade Your Checkout
Open your checkout right now and look at it with a cold eye. If all you see is a card form, you’re probably leaving money on the table—and ceding customers to competitors who advertise PayPal, Apple Pay, or Klarna on every product page.
Concrete next steps for this week:
- Decide which stack tier you’re in (Starter, Growth, Pro).
- Turn on at least one major digital wallet and, if your AOV justifies it, a BNPL option inside your existing gateway.
- Check your top three countries by revenue and add one local or pay‑by‑bank method where it clearly matters.
Your payment mix is no longer a technical afterthought—it’s one of the fastest levers you can pull to increase conversion, AOV, and customer trust in 2025. Treat it like a product decision, not paperwork, and your revenue will follow.
Unlock Full Article
Watch a quick video to get instant access.
Social Media